Aqadvisor overstocked

Last UpdatedMarch 5, 2024

by

All of my other fish seem fine, it's just the one. I do ~40% water changes every Sunday. You have 1 centerpiece fish and 6 random schools. It seems like you've got this handled. Rams do very well with angels and are stunning. 91% seems spot on. As I write this I hear them "talking"! I suspect I have 3 males and 1 female. 2 and my tanks run 6. Is this overstocked? Filters are aquaclear 50 and an aquaclear mini. Feb 10, 2020 · Originally Posted by BigJim I messed around with AqAdvisor again for the first time since it came out. Beginner Freshwater Aquarium Thanks guys. Tank #2: Single nerite, 2. Sep 24, 2015 · x9 gold cloud mountain minnows x3 platy x2 honey gourami x6 amano shrimp x1 assassin snail x5 kuhli loaches x5 panda corys AqAdvisor says that my plans will eventually overstock my tank Aug 5, 2003 · The web version is lagging a bit from that perspective. 2. A lot. I have 7 thick-lipped gouramis, 20 kuhli loach, 5 assassin snails and about 20 shrimp (cherry and amano) Most of the seasoned/experienced members here on MAC could reasonably easily stock at the 127% you hypothesised. I have an AC70 on my 29g and an AC30 and AC50 on my 20L. I got home from work tonight and noticed one of my Dalmatian mollies is swimming on its side and upside down. The Angels might eat them when it gets bigger. More sites mean more feedback, hence more accurate results. 5g livable space; 62% overstocked. Just use a standard 15 gallon with a small HOB. com my 75g stocking level is at 135% and recommends 50% water change per week. Chances are if your levels are consistent and you keep up o Oct 13, 2018 · 1419 posts · Joined 2017. 2-6. My tank is 240l (63,4g) with Eheim Professionel 4+ 250T (950l/h). 100% means you have exactly enough filtration for the amount of bioload in the tank, 200% would be you have enough filtration to handle double your current bioload, etc. I'd say the filter ratings could be made a little less conservative. And the pH will fall fairly quickly once the tank is established. The thing I like is that they take it to account bioload stocking capacity and weekly water changes. Mine is well over 200% in most of my tanks. It could also be too small for the cories depending on the species. I did cheat on the offline version by pre-calculating the surface area of each bowfronts and come up with the equivalent rectangular dimensions. . This site is just a generalized idea anyway and by no means gospel - true stocking levels are determined by experience and results. Its not overstocked in terms of bioload but you're a bit everywhere. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and… Sep 9, 2014 · This is the exact quote from aqadvisor: Your aquarium filtration capacity for above selected species is60%. (An angelfish, 11 Lake Kutubu rainbowfish, 11 black neon tetras, 20 lemon tetras, 10 panda corys and 2 bristle nose plecos in a 65, and 9 pearl gouramis, 15 serpae tetras, 10 pristella tetras, and 9 trilineatus corys in a 40 It's overstocked because of the bsrbs. 4 with < 1dGH and < 1dKH. Dec 2, 2022 · Overstocked, and understocked, are some of the most abused terms in this hobby. Recommended hardness range: 5 - 10 dH. Anyway, in your case, I'll say that your tank is very new. But with experience and first hand knowledge of your own set up you should know when a tank is overstocked. A betta typically wants lower flow in the filtration due to the long fins causing stress and/or damage to the fish. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and… Aqadvisor So, I’ve taken to use AqAdvisor because it has been highly recommended. The goal was to solve these challenges. id suggest to try and create a slope till ~10cm under the surface by using some driftwood at one side and the back of the tank. The tanks are a little full, but the water parameters are never bad. Jun 19, 2015 · Aqadvisor is a good rule of thumb for stocking fish. Last edited: May 26, 2023. Jun 2, 2014 · Filtration percentage for the calculator is determined by how much waste can your filtration handle compared to how stocked the tank is. Waste of effort trying to stock a tank in aqadvisor anyway as it's not accurate. You want larger schools compared to more species. The advised ideal is below 85% stocking and to have over 100% filtration. Due to alpha male (the largest male in the tank of that species) aggression, you will need 4 or 5 others of the same species to spread aggression. Algorithm is based on the attributes of individual species stored in the tropical fish knowledge database. It is by no means a rule and obviously research needs to be done when considering a build / stocking of your own. Most of the said seasoned/experienced members have learnt the hard way (losing fish) over the years and in a variety of ways, and know how quickly a heavily stocked aquarium can become a train wreck. He is very active, he is just swimming weird. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. The gouramis are all in hiding unless one comes out of hiding and then another will come out, chase the other back in to the plants and then zip back in to the plants. Hi there, I wanted to know if my tank is overstocked. Id go with 2 snails because your shrimp will probably breed and 3 snails would be a bit cramped for how many algae eaters you have. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and… I am of the opinion that mostly everyone overstock their tanks (even if they follow aqadvisor for example) and more importantly mix to many species, people overstock plants aswell (even in great looking tanks). Bottom line, if your water perimeters are fine, your fish seem happy and aren't sick, your tank doesn't look crowded with fish like a Pink Floyd concert with fans, or is overrun by unintended algae, and your plants are healthy and doing fine you are doing something The goal was to solve these challenges. Dont use aquaadvisor. I have plenty of aquarium filtration capacity and to do 26% water change per week(so I'll double that). To overstock, your have to be willing to clean stuff. Plants are almost always positive additions. To new tropical fish keepers: AqAdvisor. There's just too many variables. As a rule of thumb, I'd prefer to keep my tanks understocked. If you are experienced you can overstock, my 28l is overstocked with 5 juvenile platy and a baby catfish, but I have dense planting and a big filter, and I'll shift the catfish once it grows. Aug 23, 2016 · According to aqadvisor. I'm leaning toward returning the minnows to my LFS for future safety for that reason. com is an Online Aquarium Stocking Calculator Tool to help users stock and setup right levels of tropical fish and choose right filters for their aquarium tanks AqAdvisor - Intelligent Freshwater Tropical Fish Aquarium Stocking Calculator and Aquarium Tank/Filter Advisor Also, you're not really overstocked (aqadvisor says it is; but it's not by much and it's fairly conservative; so whatever). Recommended temperature range: 82. In other words, it helps to determine a healthy fish population size based on the size of your tank, and your filtration system’s capacity. Full disclosure, I often use aqadvisor when considering stocking of an aquarium. aqadvisor is a wonderful starting point, but not always the most accurate. I never noticed it doing that until tonight. If you aren’t 100% confident, then the answer is probably no. 33K subscribers in the fishtank community. Currently aqadvisor says its at 98% but I'm not sure whether to trust it. Business, Economics, and Finance. Regular water changes are essential. the tank is practically empty and its double the size almost how can it be 82% still?! 541K subscribers in the Aquariums community. Enjoy your tank 😊 AqAdvisor is a good starting point, but it's still pretty flawed, imo. Aqadvisor is kind of just a general ballpark of where you're at, it also doesn't factor in live plants which assist a little with the nitrate load in a tank that's Mar 12, 2022 · I know aqadvisor is a guideline at best but there is an interesting correlation that I've stumbled across between ADA's stocking and aqadvisor. Sure it might work for a while but then if you slack and miss a couple of waterchanges disaster is always around the corner. This doesn’t seem to be your situation. All of my tanks are “overstocked” according to aqadvisor, I do way fewer water changes then they recommend, and my parameters are perfect. In general I really don't like aqadvisor because it is not reliable for stocking a tank from scratch. Your aquarium filtration capacity for above selected species is 201%. Nitrate levels rising too high within a few days is the indicator that I would rely on The overstock is what worries me the most. Sounds like you have it up and running and are on top of things so keep it up. This article will be providing you with a helpful guide on how to use this calculator effectively. Jan 8, 2014 · Freshwater Fish and Aquariums. I did an experiment and input a bunch of my old tanks into this little calculator and never came up less than 115% stocking. Your tank is overstocked. www. Learn how you can utilize AqAdvisor to make sure you aren't overstocking your tank. com will: calculate bioloads of selected aquarium species. e. I'm new to keeping fish, but make sure you cycle your filter before adding fish, & I added my fish slowly so that my filter could adapt to dealing with the extra load. Cold water tanks and marine tanks have higher surface requirements. Aqadvisor is ridiculously conservative in most cases. I would even go below 100% if you don't have prior experience. As for algae eating, bristlenoses eat more wood Aqadvisor is generally conservative. A tank is overstocked for bioload if you can’t keep your nitrates within safe levels for your fish with regular water changes, or if you’re seeing ammonia or nitrites. A. Mine took out a school of clo-lights in a couple of days. It allows you to select how many fish you want in the tank, how many species, the sex ratio of the fish and so on. And their estimates are conservative. Filtration efficiency has nothing to do with how many gallons a filter is rated for, but rather filter media surface area. i. nitrates have been going from 10ppm to 20 ppm in about 9-10 759K subscribers in the Aquariums community. Location. (You might want to split this water change schedule to two separate 40% per week) Your aquarium stocking level is 140%. They get HUGE. I have an AC70 on my 29g and an AC30 and AC50 on In the order I added my fish: 17 columbian tetra (one got plant matter stuck in his gill and died) 5 dwarf chain loaches 5 tiger barbs 5 albino tiger barbs 5 green tiger barbs 1 red tail shark. You would also have to look at agression on other sites (or here), because, while AqAdvisor is quite good with compatibility, it isn't perfect. May 13, 2010 · I messed around with AqAdvisor again for the first time since it came out. Make sure you have plenty of filtration capacity when you are dealing with overstocked Mbuna species tanks. Neon tetras still hiding in corner 5 days after being introduced. Crypto Mostly? That's the best and worst part about aquariums lots of stuff looks great on paper just doesn't work and it won't always work for everybody. My tap water pH is 7-7. Jun 19, 2015 · AqAdvisor is a good indicator for a beginner and has probably saved a lot of over stocking disasters. Sep 12, 2010 · Assuming the hardness is 40 ppm, that's very soft, equal to 2-3 dGH. You're not overstocked from a bioload perspective. Neons are not particularly brave fish but get better in bigger groups and with fewer "competing" schools. And then you want to keep the filtration capacity over say 150% depending on what fish you keep though. That being said I think it’s a great place to start if your tank isn’t heavily planted or your new to the hobby. Note that the AqAdvisor. I know that they have a saltwater side. But it works from calculation perspective. On the other hand, a search returns both that aqadvsior is extremely conservative and often puts people way above 100% on normal fishtanks, and also that it should be at a stocking level of 85%…I’m confused. 5 situations, only one is severely overstocked. I think it’s a good albeit conservative tool. I do a 50% water change twice a week and add 2 drops of quick start in the new water as well as 5 drops of stress coat. Half my guppy tanks are technically overstocked on paper but they're fine. 937K subscribers in the Aquariums community. com your tank is very overstocked. A great feature is that it tells you how many individuals of the same species can be added. Recommended pH range: 5. Yes a planted tank is easier to keep stable and aqadvisor doesn't take that into account. Earth. Close to what I have. Ultimately what it comes down to is the 'diligent hobbyist' bit. Basically, I can say that a fluvial FX4 is running, but have nothing inside and AqAdvisor doesn't care. Yes there are obvious things like putting a common pleco in your 1 gallon tank with your goldfish, but in the 70-150% range there's so much that can put you over or under the realistic stocking limit AqAdvisor. Aqadvisor is excellent for planning out stocking and for new or unplanted tanks though. Right now there are only CPD's in there I messed around with AqAdvisor again for the first time since it came out. It says my tanks are 173% and 268% overstocked. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and… I do tend to do weekly(ish) water changes but just at my convenience. any species that require a larger tank than That's overstocked because the glass cats and swordtails need a larger tank. But yes, it does take adult size and your tank size, as u/KhalilTheGleek mentions you can switch to juvenile size if you like. You have plenty of aquarium filtration capacity. It refuses to die and was originally created back before filters had been invented which severely reduced stocking limits on tanks. 5. It says your normal shrimp tank is massively Overstocked Etc Reply reply Princeoplecs • About as accurate as the air rifles at a fair, the ones missing sights with I know AqAdvisor is known for being on the safe side and encouraging understocking. com has been built for you to share with other aquarium hobbyists. This is an important tool for anyone looking to get into the hobby or eve AqAdvisor. Is this overstocked / under filtered? Aqadvisor says I am at 91% stocking and need more filtration if I add anything. May 26, 2023. Last edited by a moderator: Sep 9, 2014. I'd also steer clear of the rummy nose. It keeps flailing around in circles on its side. You can further discuss or leave suggestions in this forum. com - Online tool to help you stock your aquarium tanks. Recommended water change schedule: 64% per week. The number of fish you can keep in a tank is very relative to your skill as a fish keeper. Just do one centerpiece, the kuhli locahes, and 1-2 other schools. According to Aqadvisor it's a little bit overstocked but I test the water every so often and everything is exactly what it should be. And then check each species on Seriously Fish so you have an accurate gauge for tank size and tank mates. For example, depending on your filtration and love of plants (or water changes), you could be well below what the tank can actually support. 4 F. Simply insert the details about your fish tank shape and dimensions, together with information about the fish species you plan on keeping, and the calculator will tell you how many fish you can fit in your aquarium. 125 - BGK, chanchito cichlid, pictus cats, silver dollars, palmas bichir. #1. Aqadvisor-anyone noticed its changed slightly? Before in my 125l tank it never warned me about size of severum yet now in a 225l it is?! In my 125l it had stocking at 98%yet with the same fish in a 225l its still at 82. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and… AqAdvisor. 8 - 7. Dec 27, 2022 · AqAdvisor makes used of its freshwater fish database and all information related to fish that are available to it. Aquaadvisor is good for some things, but not great for most. But here is the kicker though. Filter and all other components will stay because I bought them as overkill for the 10g in hopes to upgrade later. Key thing here is not to overstock the larger tank. (You might want to split this water change schedule to two separate 27% per week) Your aquarium stocking level is 139%. The more overstocked you are, the more work you have to do and the less room for mistakes you have. However, I'd probably expect to see nitrates (your tank isn't that planted); so I'd guess your test kit is either faulty or being used incorrectly. So if your home can afford a larger tank, get it. I fear your loaches would wind up Axolotl snacks. You can easily overstocked according to aqadvisor with hesvily planted tanks and overfiltration. Soft water fish will be perfectly suited to that. For instance, the AqAdvisor calculator says 105 neons in a 100-gallon aquarium is the 100% stocking level (“Your aquarium stocking level is 100%” in AqAdvisor). 5G is small though! And Posted by u/notwittyatall - 3 votes and 5 comments How accurate is aqadvisor? Help/Advice I have a 10 gallon that im setting up and was looking to put some neocaridina and some nano fish (decided on chili rasboras rather than ember tetras) and kinda wanted some snails (I like the goofy lil fellas) so i was wondering if it would be overstocked? Apr 27, 2024 · Posted April 27. hey, thanks!! with my current set up it says to change 10% of water a week, but I do more like 25-30% a week (2 different times, to keep the gravel nice & vac'd) since I have the liquid water test kit I can keep a real close eye on the nitrates. Aqadvisor has been called overly conservative over and over and over on reddit. 5g livable space; 326% overstocked. #12 · Oct 15, 2018. I didn't have filtration set. Is that overstocked? I know it's advised to keep at 85% and less, are those 6% going to change much? Jul 12, 2023 · However, Aqadvisor says I’m already overstocked, so…Dunno. AqAdvisor called my theoretical stock to be 150% for a 20g high. A place to connect with fellow fish lovers, share photos, videos, and help new fish keepers! 545K subscribers in the Aquariums community. Really just the title. com will take into account all these factors so that you can focus more on your tropical fish selections. Its a little over 15 gallons, with 11 relatively small plants growing in soil covered by thick gravel. So I'd like opinions on what you guys would realistically consider it. For slender fish, we use the value of 12 square inches of surface per length-inch of fish (or 30 sq cm/1 cm of fish) For full-bodied fish, we use the value of 20 square inches per inch (50 sq cm/1 cm) of fish. This is intentional. AqAdvisor. aqadvisor. Recommended water change schedule:48%per week. Just curious as I have heard AqAdvisor tends to overestimate and such, and wanted to hear people's thoughts! Aqadvisor says my tank is 91% stocked. They have been living in my 36g planted tank in the meantime…. Not all media types are created equal Apr 5, 2023 · 8. Crypto It's relatively accurate in my experience, although it could use a lot more detail about what can peacefully coexist in a tank or how to properly overstock african cichilds according to tank size. It does not guarantee that the selected species will completely get along in the You will probably need to do more frequent water changes, & be careful not to overfeed, but 13% isn't hugely overstocked - maybe have 2 snails instead of 3. The calculator reflects this by providing two extremes. Hey guys, I have two dojo loaches that I intend to move to a more suitable tank soon. My filtration is good, over 100%. If you keep the same choice of fish in two different sized tanks, it is almost always true that the larger of the two will contain more stable water parameters and is more tolerant against failures such as thermometer and filter failures. What is your tank stocked with? Things like size, species, diet, activity level, behavior of the fish as well as presence of live plants, filtration, surface area and water changes are all factors. It also says, for some reason, that my bristlenose plecos and albino cory cats are somehow unsuited to go with a betta. Apr 19, 2016 · According to aqadvisor I am not overstocked but I am starting to debate this. The other factor is territory, which is going to be dependent on the type of fish you have. Mbuna tanks are often overstocked. If it will even sorta fit into an axolotl's mouth, it will eventually find it's way into an axolotl's mouth. 4 - 82. The following will be the new readout for my tank. Warning: At least 5 x Discus are recommended in a group. In addition, while it is okay to overstock by say 10 or 15%, you need to be mindful of which areas in your tank you're stocking. Yes. I've had one Cory die, which I removed and took photo's of. Warning: Discus is not recommended for your tank - it may eventually outgrow your tank space, potentially reaching up to 6 inches. Apr 24, 2010 · Your aquarium filtration capacity for above selected species is 49%. I have a tank that’s like 150% stocked and I haven’t done a water change in months and it’s sitting at 0ppm ammonia 0ppm nitrite and 10-20ppm nitrate. 2 dwarf frogs. it will decrease the volume of water, but it will increase the space actively used by the fish. com website is just one person’s OPINION and the stocking calculator is NOT based on rational volume or weight considerations. My current filtration is two Marineland Penguin 350s and two sponge filters. I have a corner filter which has a flow rate of 270l/h and has an air inlet and a bigger canister Nov 15, 2009 · Although both tanks are overstocked, tank 1 has lighter bioload which means your filter load is lower and your water change volume will go down accordingly as well. People always mention them when looking at my tanks. you can further add epiphytes to the driftwood and thereby add some more structure in the upper water levels. Overstocked is that balance between filtration being sufficient to break down fish waste (AqAdvisor can be as useful a tool as any to determine this), fish not being stressed by being overcrowded (varies from species to species), and what is appealing to the eye (a matter of personal taste). The filtration I intend on using is an Aquaclear 30 plus a sponge filter. Display only suitable species When this button is pressed, the tropical fish species selection list will exclude all species that do not meet the size requirement of your aquarium. This will mean bringing over some of the old fish and adding some new as well as lots of live plants. Mar 8, 2021 · How much, according to AqAdvisor's percentages, is it ok to overstock? Like say AqAdvisor says my stock is at, say, 130%, is that alright or would that be considered "overstocked". But what does 130% mean on aqadvisor? It doesn’t say: “Your tank is overstocked. I recently added one Marineland penguin 100 as a little extra filtration, but also to build up beneficial bacteria on an extra filter to put on a quarantine tank when 762K subscribers in the Aquariums community. Aqadvisor doesn't (can't, really) take every Factor into consideration that can have a huge impact on whether or not you're actually overstocked. May 8, 2019 · AqAdvisor is a tool that is used to calculate your aquarium stocking level. com is a tool/calculator that helps you determine your tropical fish stocking plans. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and… Jun 5, 2019 · It seems strange to me that if I remove all livestock but the two nerite snails in the 2. Nitrate bottles are notorious for needing a really solid shaking prior to use. com is an intelligent online aquarium stocking calculator with knowledge database that expands! Summary of features AqAdvisor. Tank #3: Single nerite, 2. AqAdvisor isn't 100% accurate, but is a good tool, especially if you are new to the hobby. I have a 30 gallon fully established/cycled tank with a Aquaclear 110 HOB filter. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and… 725. How reliable is AqAdvisor? Hello, I've decided to upgrade my tank from 10g tall to 20g tall. Is it accurate though? For example in my 20g long with 10g sump/refugium: I will have Firefish Goby Royal Gramma Basslet 2 Occ Clowns Jan 30, 2021 · I have a couple of tanks that are wildly overstocked by following the inch per gallon rule, but they're working fine. any species that require a larger tank than That sounds like a great setup and, yes AqAdvisor is pretty accurate with stocking percentages. I'd say the filter ratings could be made a 572K subscribers in the Aquariums community. As long as you know what you're doing (mainly just keeping nitrates down with water changes) and the species are compatible and everyone has enough room you're not ever overstocked. 3 ghost shrimp. Warning: Discus requires a tank with more height 595K subscribers in the Aquariums community. Mar 21, 2014 · So I used aqadvisor for my freshwater to help stock it. Generally you will get more leeway with higher %. It does not guarantee that the selected species will completely get along in the How overstocked does aqadvisor say you are? Obviously, you want to make sure your parameters aren't swinging around and that your biofilter can handle the excess load. Jan 8, 2014 · Aqadvisor is a great place to start, but it's always best to have people look over your plan before implementation. The 1" / gallon rule is outdated and useless nowadays. . In your opinion is my tank overstocked or am I managing the bioload? As per www. This is a ridiculously low but gives the basic idea of stocking. 125 - cichlids (severums, bolivian rams, chocolate), rainbows ( turquoise, red), loaches (angelicus, zebra, kuhli and horseface), plecos (BN, RL and clown Mar 15, 2023 · The best way to work out how many fish you can keep in your tank is to use an aquarium stocking calculator. So far I don't see aggression, and everyone is very active and eating. xc du ae uv ky xt mc sd ig ao